The SEQTEST Procedure

Boundary Adjustments for Overlapping Lower and Upper bold-italic beta Boundaries

In the SEQTEST procedure, the alpha and beta spending values at the stages are used to derive the boundary values for the trial. For a two-sided design with early stopping to accept upper H 0, or to either reject or accept upper H 0, a zero beta spending at an interim stage sets the beta boundary values to missing. A small beta spending at the current or subsequent interim stage might result in overlapping of the lower and upper beta boundaries for the two corresponding one-sided tests. Specifically, this form of overlapping occurs at an interim stage k if the upper beta boundary value that is derived from the one-sided test for the upper alternative is less than the lower beta boundary value that is derived from the one-sided test for the lower alternative (Kittelson and Emerson 1999, pp. 881–882; Rudser and Emerson 2007, p. 6). You can use the BETAOVERLAP= option to specify how this type of overlapping is to be handled.

If BETAOVERLAP=ADJUST (which is the default) is specified, the procedure derives the boundary values for the two-sided design and then checks for overlapping of the two one-sided beta boundaries at the current and subsequent interim stages. If overlapping occurs at a particular stage, the beta boundary values for the two-sided design are set to missing (so the trial does not stop to accept the null hypothesis at this stage), and the beta spending values at subsequent stages are adjusted proportionally as follows.

If the beta boundary values are set to missing at stage k in a K-stage trial, the adjusted beta spending value at stage k, e prime Subscript k, is updated for these missing beta boundary values, and then the beta spending values at subsequent stages are adjusted proportionally by

e prime Subscript j Baseline equals e prime Subscript k Baseline plus StartFraction e Subscript j Baseline minus e Subscript k Baseline Over e Subscript upper K Baseline minus e Subscript k Baseline EndFraction left-parenthesis e Subscript upper K Baseline minus e prime Subscript k right-parenthesis

for j equals k plus 1 comma ellipsis comma upper K, where e Subscript j and e prime Subscript j are cumulative beta spending values at stage j before and after the adjustment, respectively.

After all these adjusted beta spending values are computed, the boundary values are then further modified for these adjusted beta spending values.

If you specify BETAOVERLAP=NOADJUST, no adjustment is made when overlapping of one-sided beta boundaries occurs.

Last updated: December 09, 2022